The title is supposed to be in Russian:
"Звезда"Okay, wow.
This is a bit of a departure for me.
I'm not sure how lucid this is, which I kind of decided to get over since it's supposed to be about madness, but....
Yeah. I could use help.
Inspired partly by:




And should be accompanied by
[link] (White Foxes, Susanne Sundfør)
You might also need to read about Vasilisa:
[link]And I forgot to mention I can't fully claim credit for the "I have seen hell" line. Check out this clip from the BBC adaptation of Elizabeth Gaskell's
North and South:
[link]“I wish I could tell you how lonely I am. How cold and harsh it is here. Everywhere there is conflict and unkindness. I think God has forsaken this place. I believe I have seen hell and it's white, it's snow-white.”And don't let me forget to mention this was composed for a contest on the topic of Insanity being hosted by #GrimGloomTaleOKAY, SO:
I desperately need critique. On EVERYTHING. I would particularly appreciate comments on these topics...
This is really supposed to show a person's disintegration into madness, but I'm not sure how well I showed that.
1. Plot arc. Can you see the character's trajectory? Can you see a story there? How does it end?
2. Consistent perspective and tone. Although this is supposed to be a madness piece, I'm concerned I'm too inconsistent in POV, at the very least.
3. Do you like the way I've used line breaks/capitalization/punctuation (or the complete lack thereof)?
4. How well do you think the imagery progresses? Despite being a madness piece, do you think there is some kind of logical flow to or connection between the images?
I guess that's what I keep coming back to - although it's a madness piece, I think I need to make some basic level of sense, and I'm worried I haven't done that.
All comments appreciated!
"a glittering necklace of asteroids"
"Madness is only a quiet hunger for those
who do not live with the skull"
"wishing for the russet hair that would blend me in"
"always / turning tailward to devour enemies of the throne"
"the most I may hope for by march is to be caught by the forest witch"
"gravity and greed are just hunger of different kinds"
"and listen to how I became the doll given to me by my mother and of how I set my own eyelids on fire"
"and how my antlers came in early and I tore them off to keep it secret"
"sleeping with the dead river"
But: the best two lines ever:
"and how this one time I caught my hair in the willow tree and spent three lifetimes as a fortuneteller."
"and I have seen hell and it is white white and leaves nowhere to hide"
Holy effffff.
As for your concerns:
1. Plot arc. Can you see the character's trajectory? Can you see a story there? How does it end?
I absolutely love this descent into madness. I mean: I totally and completely got a vision of the film The Hours. Watch it before you revise this. Seriously.
I think it needs a bit more clarification - I like how snarled and tangled it is. I just think it needs a bit of honing. Here's my contradictory advice: a streamline of story arch through the snarl. lol If that makes sense.
2. Consistent perspective and tone. Although this is supposed to be a madness piece, I'm concerned I'm too inconsistent in POV, at the very least.
I think the POV is lovely. Especially when you streamline a bit as you expand and contract the language of the piece. POV is so strong, its issues will take care of themselves as you work through other issues
3. Do you like the way I've used line breaks/capitalization/punctuation (or the complete lack thereof)?
Okay. I am good with the minimal capitalization/punctuation. Just make sure when you actually capitalize/punctuate, it means something. Nothing in a poem is arbitrary. Especially "I" - as in:
iv. even buildings are not safe.
i am allowed outside if I am good.
One of these January mornings I will be good enough
I think capitalizing only the very first "I" of the poem and those last two "I"s will be super strong!
4. How well do you think the imagery progresses? Despite being a madness piece, do you think there is some kind of logical flow to or connection between the images?
YES. I love the tangledness (that's totes a word
I think having the section numerals is really helpful. That helps the reader understand that we're moving to a new idea, but not fully leaving behind the previous ideas.
Honestly: I think you could double the length of this poem. You should play with adding more lines to help boost the images you already have in the poem. Color / sound / other poetic devices - use these to help pump more meaning into your images.
Can't wait to see the edits!!!!!!
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.